Rise in Violent Incidents Highlights Need for Focus on Health and Safety in Schools

Created on: 22 Dec 2023


The EIS has said that health and safety must be a priority in schools to ensure a safe working environment for staff and pupils alike.

Recent figures released by each of the EIS, the Scottish Government and the OECD have highlighted the growing number of violent and abusive incidents in schools.

The EIS has also, today, released information on personal injury cases won on behalf of members over the past year, including a number of major violent incident injury awards. The highest award achieved was for a teacher assaulted in the workplace, who received £180,000 as compensation for the serious injury that they suffered.

Commenting, EIS General Secretary Andrea Bradley said, "Pursuing compensation for teachers injured or assaulted in our schools is never a pleasant task, but it is an area of work where the EIS will always give its all on behalf of our members. No-one deserves to suffer injury or assault in their workplace, which is why local authorities – as the employers of teachers – have a legal duty of care to ensure a safe working environment for all school staff.

"Worryingly, as the rise in violent incidents in recent years can attest, our schools are currently not as safe as they should be for staff and pupils."

Ms Bradley continued, "In previous years, when the EIS reported on personal injury settlements achieved on behalf of teachers, the vast majority would be related to slips, trips and falls in the workplace.

"This year, however, more than 40% of the settlements that we are highlighting were because teachers had been assaulted in their place of work. These cases have resulted in payments of more than £220,000 for the five teachers concerned, with the largest single settlement amounting to a £180,000 payment on account of the very serious injuries sustained by our member."

Ms Bradley added, "Local authorities and the Scottish Government must take urgent action to make our schools properly safe, and to ensure that all staff and pupils can work without fear of assault or injury.

"The EIS campaign Stand up for Quality Education is calling for additional resources for schools, including additional staffing, to allow schools to better meet the needs of all young people, including those who are more likely to exhibit distressed and violent behaviour as a result of unmet additional support needs, and to reduce incidents of violence and aggression in the classroom.

"Local authorities and the Scottish Government must work together to deliver safer schools, so that school staff can work without fear of physical harm for any reason and so that all young people can learn in a safe, secure and nurturing environment."

A list of this year’s injury settlements for EIS members is detailed below.

 

Claim

Nature of Claim

Award

Assault Claim

Member was assaulted at their place of work causing serious injury.

£180,000

Accident Claim

Member walking to car in the school carpark and had to walk on a path to access the driver car door.  As member went onto the path both feet slipped and one leg landed back on the path and the whole body weight landed on leg. Member suffered a broken ankle in 2 places and had to undergo an operation.

£135,000

Accident Claim

Member slipped on wet floor in the workplace. This resulted in severe damage to knee and foot.

£100,000

Health Claim

Member developed health condition as a result of exposure to various substances in the course of their employment.

£60,000

Assault Claim

Member assaulted on three separate occasions.

£28,469

Accident Claim

Member walked into the toilet, where the floor was wet and very slippery. No warning signs had been displayed. Member slid along the wet floor, going over on ankle and twisting knee. Member fell on back, and in the process, twisted the ankle further.  Member suffered a fracture to Fibula bone.

£8,050

Accident Claim

Member pushed fire door open and the closing mechanism broke at that point hitting member and causing injury to left arm and shoulder.

£8,000

Accident Claim

Member caught foot on a door stop which sits a distance from the wall. This caused member to trip causing forehead to hit the floor. In addition, members glasses cut their forehead.  Member had to undergo stitches in forehead.

£6,750

Assault Claim

Member was punched in the face by a pupil and suffered a hairline fracture to jaw.

£6,020

Assault Claim

Member was headbutted causing bleeding to mouth and damaged teeth.

£4,500

Accident Claim

Member was using the marked pedestrian crossing to cross the main access road to the school grounds. Member checked both ways and the road was clear. When member was just over halfway across, they noticed that a vehicle entering the school from the main road. Member was struck by the vehicle and knocked to the ground landing heavily and foot was run over by car. The markings on the crossing were faded so this could have been improved.

£3,220

Assault Claim

Member was assaulted while trying to break up a fight between pupils. Member sustained a laceration to temple which required stitches. 

£1,500

 

Total Awards

£541,499